Update Murdrs College Idaho: The mixture of 3 unknown DNA people found under Madison Mogen's nails, Deposit shows

Boise, Idaho – A mixture of three unknown DNA people was found under a 21 -year university, the nails of the students in Idaho, after she and another three Students were killed at a house outside the campus in November 2022reveals a new record.

The new evidence of the victim Madison Mogen came more than two years after she and Kaylee Goncalves, 21, Xana Kernodle, 20, and Ethan Chapin, were fatally stabbed in Moscow, Idaho. Bryan Kohberger, a student graduate from the Washington State University in Criminology, is facing four charges of first -degree murder.

A mixture of three unknown DNA people was found under one of the nails of the victim in College College, a new recording.

In a motion deposited last month, the defense demanded that the DNA evidence be kept from the jury in the future punishment process with Kohberger’s death, because the jurors might think that the DNA is Kohberger and, according to the defense, is not.

“Allowing such a testimony would violate the federal and state constitutional rights of Mr. Kohberger on the process of the knife

In Kohberger’s behalf he was introduced in Kohberger’s name, and his trial will begin in August. He faces death punishment if convicted.

In the testimony of the great jury, the forensic scientist Jade Miller discussed the results of the tests on a nail cuttings in Mogen’s left hand, according to the movement. The defense claimed that the testimony would confuse and deceive the jury, adding that the evidence is overly prejudice.

The document shows that preliminary tests were performed on the nail cuts and a “probability report” was calculated that, according to the defense, it was proven to be inconclusive. Testing the states of movement offered a “probability report for Mr. Kohberger” in the analysis, but any conclusion is reduced in deposit.

He would prejudice Kohberger because he could allow the jury to deduce that inconclusive data would mean that his DNA could be present in the sample, he said.

According to the defense motion, testing involved a comparison of hypotheses, “not a declaration of identity or probability of identity”.

Two hypotheses were analyzed: one is that the DNA belongs to Madison Mogen, her best friend Goncalves and to an unknown person. The other is that the DNA belongs to Mogen and two unrelated individuals.

Mogen, a major senior marketing at Coeur d’Alene, and Goncalves was found dead on the same bed at the Kings Road House on November 13, 2022.

Revelation probably means that defense has more in their arsenal with additional DNA discoveries, said Misty Marris, a lawyer who closely followed the Kohberger case. Nail DNA may not be related to crime, she said.

“When you see it under the nails, the argument will be … that there is a scratch that someone fought back,” Marris explained. “From the perspective of criminal prosecution, the argument is, well, it is not necessarily, because there are a lot of different ways to be able to reach somewhere.”

Kohberger excluded from DNA mixture, supports defense

The defense states that they have done independent laboratory tests that excluded Kohberger from the DNA mixture, according to registration.

However, the defense admits that these evidence was presented to a great jury by the prosecutors, because they sought a requisition at the beginning of 2023. I also write, “The state claimed that the testimony was presented to the great jury as an expulsor and an effort to cause favorable evidence for Mr. Kohberger.”

At this moment, the court did not post an answer from the prosecutors.

Marris said that the criminal prosecution has an ethical obligation to return everything that can be expulsor.

Defense will probably claim that there are reasonable doubts that Kohberger has committed crimes, she said.

“Their argument will be that, once this investigative genetic genealogy match and Kohberger were made, the law enforcement has essentially put,” Marris said. “He did not interested in anything else, so much that he did not even interested that there is additional DNA evidence, both at the property and now the person of one of the students.”

To demonstrate reasonable doubts, the defense will probably argue that there has been a significant failure in the investigation to follow all possible ways to find the guilty of attractive crime, Marris said. “You have this other potential DNA set that could have determined the investigators if it was followed by someone else and this will be a huge component of the argument,” she said.

The revelation comes while several DNA samples were challenged by defense.

The most important evidence of criminal prosecution is a DNA sample taken from a knife sheath left at the crime site. Investigators then used investigative genetic genealogy, a criminal field that combines DNA analysis with genealogical research, to connect that sample to Kohberger’s family, according to prosecutors. The subsequent Testing of the DNA found that Kohberger was a “statistical match” with the sample, which led to his arrest, according to prosecutors.

In order to combat this evidence, his defense team has repeatedly questioned the use, legality and accuracy of the DNA testing at each stage of the process. In a closed hearing last month, the testimony from several witnesses raised questions about how investigators used the DNA sample in the knife sheath to identify Kohberger as a suspect. In addition, the addition of Barlow’s defense to his legal team supports his expertise on this topic.